Urban Anthropology:  Past, Present, and Future

Anthony P. Andrews & Maria Vesperi
Offices and Office Hours:
     Andrews: CHL 212; Wednesday 1-3 pm, or by appointment -- andrews@ncf.edu
     Vesperi: CHL 233; Tuesday 3:30-5, Friday 9-10:30, or by appointment -- (727) 896-1109

Fall 2007
Tues & Fri: 12:30- 1:50

Anthro Lab

 

Course Description

Anthropologists have developed a variety of approaches to the study of urbanism as a fundamental facet of the human experience in recent millennia. Through a survey of cases, from Sumer to Mexico City to Miami, we will explore a range of techniques and theoretical approaches and evaluate their contributions to our contemporary understanding of the nature and culture of cities.  The seminar will focus on several themes, including the origin of cities, conflict in relation to class, ethnicity, and racialized constructions, urban change, and urban planning.

Requirements and Evaluation

Readings will include the texts listed below and a large body of material available on reserve. Several videos are also scheduled to be shown on Monday evenings in the Anthro Lab at 7:30 pm., on the weeks indicated on the syllabus. Evaluation of student performance will be based on class participation and three papers of 1500 words each (6 double-spaced pages). These papers will take the form of critiques, each addressing at least two reading assignments from the syllabus in a comparative focus, plus two outside sources in support of the critical arguments.  Students will be encouraged to share their outside sources by compiling a class bibliography throughout the semester.

Required Texts

Andrews, Anthony P.

1995     First Cities. St. Remy Press, Montreal // Smithsonian Books, Washington, D.C.

Gmelch, George, and Walter P. Zenner (eds.)

2002     Urban Life. 4th edition. Waveland Press, Prospect Heights.

Low, Setha, and Denise Lawrence-Zuñiga (eds)

2003     The Anthropology of Space and Place. Locating Culture. Blackwell Publishing, Malden, MA.

Portes, Alejandro, and Alex Stepick

1993     City on the Edge: The Transformation of Miami. University of California Press, Berkeley

CLASS SCHEDULE AND READINGS

AUGUST

Introduction to Urban Issues

Aug  31             The Economist

                           1985     The World Goes to Town.    The Economist, May 5.  [ER]

Overview of Historical Approaches to the Study of Urban Life

Sept  4

Dickens, Charles

1985    (orig. 1842)  An American Railroad.  Lowell and Its Factory System. From American Notes. A Journey, by C. Dickens: 61-69. [ER].  Also available online at www.readbookonline.net/read/2388/11499/   -- read section on the Lowell Factory System.

Engels, Fredrich

1968    (orig. 1845) The Great Towns. From The Condition of the Working Class in England (W.O. Henderson and W.H. Chaloner, trans.): 30-87.   [ER]

Schorske, Carl

1968    The Idea of the City in European Thought: Voltaire to Spengler. In Urbanism in World Perspective (S. Fava, ed.): 409-24.  [ER]

Weber, Max

1921    The Nature of the City. From The City, by M. Weber. Also in Classic Essays on the Culture of Cities (R. Sennett, ed., 1969): 23-46.  [ER]

Overview of Contemporary Approaches

Sept  7

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Wirth, Louis

2002     (orig. 1938) Urbanism as a Way of Life. In Gmelch & Zenner: 65-82.

Low, Setha

1996    The Anthropology of Cities: Imagining and Theorizing the City. Annual Review of Anthropology, 25: 383-409.  [ER]

McDonogh, Gary W.

1993    The Geography of Emptiness. In The Cultural Meaning of Urban Space (R. Rotenberg and G.M. McDonogh, eds.): 3- 15.   [ER]

Rotenberg, Robert

2002     (orig. 1996) The Metropolis and Everyday Life. In Gmelch & Zenner: 93-105

Sept 11       Films:  Berlin:  Symphony of a City;  Metropolis (Monday, 7:30pm).

Murray, Tim, and Penny Crock

2005     Exploring the Archaeology of the Modern City:  Issues of Scale, Integration and Complexity.  International Journal of Historical Archaeology, 9 (2):  89-109. [ER]

Rathje, William L.

1989     Rubbish! The Atlantic Monthly, December: 99-109. [ER]

LaRoche, Cheryl J., and Michael L. Blakey

1997    Seizing Intellectual Power: The Dialogue at the New York African Burial Ground.  Historical Archaeology, 31 (3): 84-106. [ER]

The Prehistoric and Preindustrial City

Sept 14       Andrews: Chap. 1.

 

Smith, Michael E.

2002     The Earliest Cities. In Gmelch & Zenner: 3-19.

Sjoberg, Gideon.

2002     (orig, 1955) The Preindustrial City. In Gmelch & Zenner: 20-31.

Childe, V. Gordon

1950    The Urban Revolution. Town Planning Review 21: 3-17. Also in The Rise and Fall of Civilizations (J.A. Sabloff and C.C. Lamberg-Karlovsky, eds., 1974): 6-14. [ER]

The Earliest Cities: Mesopotamia, Egypt, and Asia

Sept  18      Andrews: Chaps. 2-5.

Stone, Elizabeth C., and Paul Zimansky

1995     The Tapestry of Power in a Mesopotamian City. Scientific American, 272 (4; April): 118-23. [ER]

Morell, Virginia

2001    The Pyramid Builders. National Geographic, 12 (5; November): 78-99.

Yates, Robin D.S.

1997    The City State in Ancient China. In The Archaeology of City States. Cross Cultural Approaches (D.L. Nichols and T.H. Charlton, eds.): 71-90. [ER]

Sept  21     

White, Peter T.

1982    The Temples of Angkor. National Geographic, 161 (5; May): 548-89. [ER]

Kuppinger, Petra

1998    The Giza Pyramids: Accommodating Tourism, Leisure and Consumption. City & Society, Annual Review, 1998: 105-19. [ER]

Herzfeld, Michael

2003   (orig. 1991) A Place in History: Social and Monumental Time in a Cretan Town. In Low & Lawrence-Zuñiga: 363-69.

Ancient Cities of the New World: Mesoamerica

Sept  25      Film:  El Mirador:  A Preclassic Maya City (In class).

Andrews:  Chaps 6-7.

Matheny, Ray T.

1987     An Early Metropolis Uncovered: El Mirador. National Geographic, 172 (3; Sept.): 316-39.

Sept  28     

Haviland, William A.

1970    Tikal, Guatemala, and Mesoamerican Urbanism. World Archaeology, 2: 186-98. [ER]

 Stuart, George E.

1995    The Timeless Vision of Teotihuacán. National Geographic, 188 (6; Dec.): 2-35.

Calnek, Edward E.

1976    The Internal Structure of Tenochititlan. In The Valley of Mexico (E.R. Wolf, ed.): 287-302.  [ER]

OCTOBER

Ancient Cities of the New World:  Andean Region

Oct  2          Andrews: Chap. 8.

Pozorski, Shelia, and Thomas Pozorski

1994     Early Andean Cities. Scientific American, 270 (6; June): 66-72.  [ER]

Oct  5

Moseley, Michael E.

1975     Chan Chan: Andean Alternative of the Pre-Industrial City. Science, 187 (4173): 219-25.  [ER]

Von Hagen, Adriana, and Craig Morris

1998    City and Countryside in the Inka Empire. Chapter 8 from The Cities of the Ancient Andes, by A. von Hagen and C. Morris. [ER]

Migration, Poverty, and Upward Mobility in Modern Latin America

Oct  9         Film:  El Norte  (Monday, 7:30)

Kandell, Jonathan

1996    Mexico's Megalopolis. In I Saw a City Invincible. Urban Portraits of Latin America (G.M. Joseph and M.D.Szuchman, eds.): 181-201. [ER]

Fojas, Camilla

2007    Borderlined in the Global City (of Angels).  In Urban Imaginaries: Locating the Modern City (Alev Cinar & Thomas Bender, eds.): 37-54.  University of  Minnesota Press, Minneapolis. [ER]

Oct  12       Lewis, Oscar

2002     (orig. 1966) The Culture of Poverty. In Gmelch & Zenner: 269-78.

Goode, Judith

2002     How Urban Ethnography Counters Myths about the Poor. In Gmelch & Zenner: 279-95.

Kemper, Robert V.

2002    (orig. 1996) Migration and Adaptation: Tzintzuntzeños in Mexico City and Beyond. In Gmelch & Zenner: 193-204.

FALL BREAK

The Individual and the City

Oct 23         Film:  Midnight Cowboy (Monday, 7:30 pm).

Durkheim, Emile

1963     Modern Social Pathology.  In Emile Durkheim. Selections from his work, with an introduction and commentaries by George Simpson: 69-84. Thomas Y. Crowell, NY. [ER]

Milgram, Stanley

2002    (orig. 1970) The Urban Experience: A Psychological Analysis. In Gmelch & Zenner: 83-92.

Nelson, Nici

2002     (orig. 1996) Surviving in the City: Coping Strategies of Female Migrants in Nairobi, Kenya. In Gmelch & Zenner: 235-52.

Optional:  Ferguson, James

1997    The Country and the City on the Copperbelt. In Culture/Power/Place (A.Gupta and J. Ferguson, eds.): 137-54. [ER]

Oct  26        Film:  Urban Garden:  Fighting for Life and Beauty (in class)

Peterson, David

1997    Research Report: Community Gardens in New York City. North American Dialogue 4 (1). Available at http://www.stpt.usf.edu/-jsokolov/311gardenpap.htm

Optional:  Susser, Ida

2001    Poverty and Homelessness in U.S. Cities. In Cultural Diversity in the United States (Ida Susser and Thomas C. Patterson, eds.): 229-49. Blackwell Publishers, Malden, MS. [ER]

Kinship and Community in Urban Life

Oct 30         Film:  Avalon (Monday, 7:30 pm).

Orvar, Lofgren

2003   The Sweetness of Home: Class, Culture and Family Life in Sweden. In Low & Lawrence-Zuņiga: 142-59.

Gounis, Kostas

1966     Urban Marginality and Ethnographic Practice: On the Ethics of Fieldwork. City & Society, Annual Review, 1996: 108-18.

Gregory, Steven

2003    (orig. 1998)  Black Corona: Race and the Politics of Place in an Urban Community. In Low & Lawrence-Zuñiga: 284-97.

NOVEMBER

Solidarity and Conflict

Nov  2

Merry, Sally

2002     (orig. 1996)  Urban Danger: Life in a Neighborhood of Strangers. In Gmelch & Zenner: 115-26.

D'Emilio, John

1983    Sexual Politics, Sexual Communities: The Making of a Homosexual Minority in the United States, 1940-1970. Read excerpts.

McDonogh, Gary W.

2003    (orig. 1992)  Myth, Space, and Virtue: Bars, Gender, and Change in Barcelona’s Barrio Chino. In Low & Lawrence-Zuñiga: 264-83.

Nov  6         Film:  Do the Right Thing (Monday, 7:30 pm)

Berman, Marshall

1997    Justice/Just Us: Rap and Social Justice in America. In The Urbanization of Injustice (A. Merrifield and E. Swyngedouw, eds.): 161-79.

Miller, Benjamin

1987    The Colonial Polo Club: An Examination of Class Processes in the Suburban-Rural Fringe. In Cities of the United States: Studies in Urban Anthropology (L. Mullings, ed.): 198-216.

Structure and Symbol

Nov  9         Bourdieu, Pierre

2003     (orig. 1971) The Berber House. In Low & Lawrence-Zuņiga: 131-41

Pellow, Deborah

2003     The Architecture of Female Seclusion in West Africa. In Low & Lawrence-Zuņiga: 160-83.

Low, Setha M.

2003    The Edge and the Center: Gated Communities and the Discourse of Urban Fear. In Low & Lawrence-Zuņiga: 284-97.

Optional:  Chang, Sen-Dou

1977    The Morphology of Walled Capitals. From The City in Late Imperial China, by G.W. Skinner: 75-100. [ER]

Nov  13       Film:  Wild Style (Monday, 7:30 pm).

Freeman, Richard

2001    The City as Misè-en-scène: A Visual Exploration of the Culture of the Politics in Buenos Aires. Visual Anthropology Review, 17 (1): 36-59. [ER]

Rabinow, Paul

2003     (orig. 1982) Ordonnance.  Discipline, Regulation. In Low & Lawrence-Zuñiga: 353-62.

Davis, Mike

1995    Fortress Los Angeles:  The Militarization of Urban Space.  In Metropolis:  Center and Symbol of our Times.  Main Trends of the Modern World (Philip Kasinitz, ed.): 355-68.  New York University Press, New York.  Available at  http://www.lcc.gatech.edu/~broglio/1101/davis.html

Health, Welfare, Institutions, and Responses

Nov  16

Schell, Lawrence

2002     Human Health and the City. In Gmelch & Zenner: 32-52.

Yeoh, Brenda

2000    From Colonial Neglect to Post-Independence Heritage: The housing landscape in the central area of Singapore. City & Society, XII (1): 103-24.

Hersker, A.L., and W. Leap

1996    Representation, Subjectivity and Ethics in Urban Gay Ethnography. City & Society, Annual Review,1996: 142-47.

Optional:  Shilts, Randy

1987    And the Band Played On.  Read excerpts.

Life and Work

Nov  20       Film:  Modern Times (Monday, 7:30 pm).

Powers, Madelon

1997    The "Poor Man's Friend":  Saloonkeeper's, Workers, and the Code of Reciprocity in U.S. Barrooms, 1870-1920.  In The Making of Urban America, 2nd ed. (R.A. Mohl, ed.): 153-66.  [ER]

Mitchell, Joseph

1993    The Old House at Home (pp. 3-22), and All You Can Hold for Five Bucks (pp. 291-302) From Up in the Old Hotel.  [articles originally published in The New Yorker in 1939-40]

Seifert, Donna J.

1991    Within Site of the White House:  The Archaeology of Working Women.  Historical Archaeology, 25 (4): 82-108.  [ER]

Gable, Eric and Richard Handler

2003    After Authenticity at an American Heritage Site. In Low & Lawrence-Zuñiga: 370-86.

Nov 23 -- THANKSGIVING BREAK

Nov  27       Film:  The Japanese Version (Monday, 7:30 pm).

Bestor, Theodore C.

2003     (orig. 2001) Markets and Places: Tokyo and the Global Tuna Trade. In Low & Lawrence-Zuñiga: 284-97.

Yukseker, Deniz

2007    Economy and  Gender in the Urban Borderland: The Public Culture of Laleli, Istanbul.  In Urban Imaginaries: Locating the Modern City   (Alev Cinar & Thomas Bender, eds.): 17-36.  University of  Minnesota Press, Minneapolis. [ER]

Kelley, Robin

1997    Looking to Get Paid: How Some Black Youth Put Culture to Work.  From Yo’ Mama’s Disfunktional: Fighting the Culture Wars in Urban America, by Robin Kelley:  43-77.  Beacon Press, Boston. [ER]

Urban Transformations and the Future

Nov  30        Portes, Alejandro, and Alex Stepick

1993    City on the Edge: The Transformation of Miami.

Zenner, Walter P.

2002    Beyond Urban and Rural. Communities in the 21st Century. In Gmelch & Zenner: 53-60.

DECEMBER

Dec 4         Film:  Holding Ground (Monday, 7:30 pm).

Molavi, Ashfin

2007    Sudden City.  A feverish dream of the future springs from the sands in Dubai.  National Geographic, 211 (1; January): 94-113.